SCHUMER MELTDOWN: Chuck Slams Supreme Court’s Decision to ‘Disenfranchise’ Americans

If the statute explicitly articulates that states should purge voters who are caught up in a "notify, wait, and purge" regime, why would the statute also include the words "except that no registrant may be removed exclusively by reason of a failure to vote" in the very same sentence that calls for such purges unless these words were meant to limit the scope of the purges?

The case, Husted v. A. Philip Randolph Institute, was taken to the high court after the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in favor of OH resident Larry Harmon, who'd been removed from the state's registered voters list. If it finds voters have moved, they are contacted by voter registration, he said. He was joined by his four conservative colleagues in an opinion that drew praise from Republican officials and conservative scholars.

Six states have similar laws, according to the Brennan Center for Justice.

In the past, the Justice Department has opposed Ohio's process as inconsistent with federal law. Under the law, which was previously invalidated by an appeals court in 2016, the state sends a notice to voters to confirm eligibility after a two year period of not voting. "It does not", Justice Alito wrote.

Monday's Supreme Court opinion did not deal with whatever alleged discriminatory effect Ohio's purge protocol had.

While much of the nation's attention is on how Donald Trump is sabotaging America overseas, his Supreme Court nominee Neil Gorsuch used his stolen seat to cast the deciding vote in a 5-4 decision damaging our democracy here at home.

Breyer pointed out that about 1 million OH registered voters - or 13 percent of the state's voting population - did not send back their cards, and "the streets of Ohio's cities are not filled with moving vans".

The procedure "does not strike any registrant exclusively by reason of the failure to vote", Justice Samuel Alito wrote for the majority. If they respond, they are maintained on the voter rolls, he said. The majority of the Supreme Court concluded that Ohio's process didn't violate the law because the failure to return a notice indicates the voter has moved and is therefore ineligible to vote. Those who don't respond and then don't vote in the next four years are kicked off the rolls.

"Voters should not be purged from the rolls simply because they have exercised their right not to vote", he said in a statement. "First with the Voting Rights Act and today with giving the green light to an atrocious use-it-or-lose-it approach to voter registration".

But Ohio's law was considered the harshest in the nation because it kick-started the purging process after only two years.

Justice Stephen Breyer, countered in his dissent: "In my view, Ohio's program does just that".

In September 2016, a federal appeals court ruled against OH, saying that 7,515 ballots that had been struck could be cast in the that fall's election.

Absent evidence that Ohio's rules are based on discriminatory intent - and none was presented - OH shouldn't be estopped from attempts, in compliance with federal statutes, to maintain the integrity of its registrations rolls merely because members of certain groups may be unwilling, disproportionately, to take the simple measures needed to stay eligible. OH is the only one that starts the removal process after failing to vote in only one election, the center said. Ohio's process, he claims, "does not strike any registrant exclusively by reason of the failure to vote".

Justice Sotomayor, in addition to joining the main dissent, also wrote separately to emphasize how voter purge schemes like Ohio's have a disproportionate impact on low-income voters and minority voters.

After the last presidential election, the department switched sides in the case, Husted v. A. Philip Randolph Institute, No. 16-980.

Adding to the tension in the case, the Trump administration reversed the position taken by the Obama administration and backed Ohio's method for purging voters.


Popular
  • Trump, French president get into another handshake duel

    Trump, French president get into another handshake duel

    In a statement, a spokesman for Trudeau did not address Trump's insults. Donald Trump is embarking for the North Korea negotiations in a slump.
    30-year-old dies in shooting incident in Bray

    30-year-old dies in shooting incident in Bray

    Taylor, a boxing coach, is the father and former trainer of Olympic and world champion boxer Katie Taylor. There is still a heavy police presence at the club while forensic officers carry out their investigation.
    Apple just made Apple Watch a lot smarter for runners

    Apple just made Apple Watch a lot smarter for runners

    Two new workouts , yoga and hiking , can be tracked on the watch when the software update rolls out later this year. Webkit content can be displayed in notifications now, and just like on iOS 12, notifications are grouped by app.
  • Wendy's Shades IHOP Over Name Change to IHOb in Savage Tweet

    Wendy's Shades IHOP Over Name Change to IHOb in Savage Tweet

    The change is a temporary push to be recognized as more than a breakfast destination, but for its lunch and dinner options, too. Another asked why the restaurant couldn't become the International House of Brunch and start serving mimosas.
    State Dept: US Diplomats in Cuba Getting Medical Exams Following Sonic Attack

    State Dept: US Diplomats in Cuba Getting Medical Exams Following Sonic Attack

    President Donald Trump, which has partly rolled back a detente with Cuba, responded a year ago by sharply drawing down U.S. Recall that from China sent several American diplomats and their family members to undergo medical examinations.
    'Wonder Woman 2': Geoff Johns Teases

    'Wonder Woman 2': Geoff Johns Teases "WW84"

    It grossed more than 821 million dollars on a budget of 149 million dollars, breaking records for a female-directed movie. If the sequel follows the format of the first film, it could also include a bookend scenes set during the present day.
  • Liverpool deal to sign Nabil Fekir collapses as Lyon end negotiations

    Liverpool deal to sign Nabil Fekir collapses as Lyon end negotiations

    Fekir scored 21 goals and added nine assists in 39 appearances for Lyon last season. There is something logical, it has already been done for others".
    Why Mercedes is the real Canada favourite - F1

    Why Mercedes is the real Canada favourite - F1

    Mercedes were first out in Q3 and smashed the records, Bottas topping Hamilton in 1:10.857 before Vettel beat that. Vettel was delighted with his lap, which was Ferrari's first pole in Canada since 2001. "I'm happy for them".

    Trump escalates fight with ABC after Roseanne cancellation

    I was still wrong 2 dehumanize them-they r not my enemy, harboring hate & anger is my enemy. She wrote, as CNN reports: "guys I did something unforgivable, so do not defend me.
  • Porsche Taycan - Mission E Gets a New Name

    Porsche Taycan - Mission E Gets a New Name

    Porche revealed on Friday that the company's first fully electric auto name will be Taycan . Even with that, adding range back in should be more rapid than with most electric vehicles.
    Jordan's King Replaces Embattled PM to Defuse Anti-Government Protests

    Jordan's King Replaces Embattled PM to Defuse Anti-Government Protests

    Jordan was rocked by unrest in 2012 when the International Monetary Fund told the government to lift gasoline prices. Police said on Monday the protests remained under control, though officers had detained 60 people in recent days.
    Hundreds rallied against federal buyout of Kinder Morgan in Vancouver

    Hundreds rallied against federal buyout of Kinder Morgan in Vancouver

    Climate Justice Saskatoon said their concerns remain when it comes to climate change, spill risks and job creation. Political observers said it's not clear how the pipeline's resurrection will effect next spring's election.

CONNECT